On the ground in D.C., Maryland and Virginia

Military, Reagan National Airport pledge to work on helicopter noise

September 23, 2010 - 05:00 AM
Text size Decrease Increase
Helicopter Noise Meeting
Col. Scott E. Sanborn from Army Air Operations speaks to residents about helicopter noise. (Photo: TBD Staff)

Since 2007, Arlington resident Ed Hilz has filed 350 helicopter noise complaints with the Federal Aviation Administration--including one this week. There hasn’t been any marked reduction in the frequency of helicopter trips, or the height at which they fly over his Fairlington neighborhood, though.

The noise is jarring, and has caused structural damage to some people’s homes, he says. The helicopters often veer off the arranged routes, which follow major thoroughfares like Interstate 395 or U.S. Route 7. And there are times when the helicopters are just 150 or 200 feet above homes.

But more annoying is the fact that he never received a response to any of of his complaints.

“I personally reported over 350 incidents where helicopters were flying off route, and there wasn't any dialogue since March of 2007,” Hilz told members military and government personnel at a meeting on the helicopter noise issue in Arlington last night. “You would report these incidents, and you wouldn't hear anything.

Last night’s meeting was the brainchild of Arlington board member Mary Hynes and Fairfax County Board of Supervisors member Gerald Highland, two local officials that have become a sounding board for residents plagued by helicopter flyovers. Residents “get it” when it comes to the need for helicopter trips overhead, Hynes assured military members at the meeting. “But we’re eager to explore whether modest adjustments could be made with little to no impact to mission accomplishment,” she added.

Hynes is also the chair of the aviation policy committee of the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments, which hosted last night’s meeting. She says military trips make up 51 percent of the the helicopter trips through the region, and residents tend to attribute many of those trips to the Davison Army Airfield at Fort Belvoir -- even if that’s not accurate.

Fort Belvoir’s Colonel Scott E. Sanborn, who just took over leadership of the Army Air Operations Group for the region earlier this month, says the base does all it can to reduce disruptive flights. “We do take this issue very seriously,” he said.

The larger problem is that when complaints come in to the military or the FAA, the actual helicopter in question could be related to any number of military units flying missions in the D.C. area, and it can be tough to tell where the trouble spots are.

Hynes is looking for someone to look at the overall flight scenarios in the region and identify “hot spots” where helicopters regularly fly too low, or veer off course into residential neighborhoods. “That's what we're all kind of thinking about, do you look at that for patterns,” she asked.

Hyland is also looking for an answer as to whether these flights are vital to national security. “If it has to happen then, i have no problem saying to my community, you have to suck it up, they need to do that mission,” said Hyland. “But we would certainly like to know, is it necessary to overfly residential communities, and is there an alternative to overflying residential comm during certain periods of time.”

Most of the agencies with air traffic in the area either don’t have the manpower or the security permissions, to release that kind of information. But Bob Laser, operations manager for the air control tower at Reagan National Airport, says he might be able to help by doing a case study of a two-week period of helicopter traffic and complaints.

A wrap-up of that info would necessarily lack specific flight information, but it could identify the patterns Hynes mentioned. “What we can really get out of that, is here are the hot spots, so we can tell everyone, ‘as best you can, avoid those hot spots,’ or ‘if you can choose between this or that route, don't always choose that one,’” Laser said. Air traffic control at DCA has access to all entities that fly through its airspace, and thus could bring together all the necessary parties for that conversation, Laser added.

He said he would organize that meeting and reach out to local officials about it. For her part, Hynes seemed satisfied with the development, although she added that the initial study should lead to more regular interaction between the interested parties. “I think we have a game plan. It appears that the message on regular communication has been heard,” she said.

What about Hilz? He’s optimistic. Moreso than he was in 2007, which is the last time DOD agreed to host one of these meetings. “I’m encouraged at what came out of here tonight, and the commitment made,” he said.

Tags:

2 Comments

  • View all

Sort by:

  1. TVmercenary TVmercenary

    Peter Roof

    Sep 23, 2010 - 09:50:18 AM

    I have flown in helicopters as a TV news camera person for the last 10 years with many great pilots. They know the airspace and I've learned why they fly in certain manners. The area you describe is a very popular route known as "splitting the Ps." "P" is for the two prohibited areas over the Mall and the VP mansion. See: http://skyvector.com/?ll=38.88650674105427,-77.09686261460251&chart=203&zoom=3 The route is the shortest for medical flights from N.Va to Washington Hospital Center. Also, the altitude restriction for helos in this area is 300 feet to stay below arriving and departing flights from DCA. When flying low pilots should fly at a fast airspeed in order to maintain sufficient momentum in the event of engine failure. This energy can be transferred to the rotor if an emergency landing is necessary. I am not sure how civilians on the ground know how high an aircraft is flying. Other than the limits it's difficult to know. Most pilots like to fly 1,000 feet above the ground. This allows for sufficient buffer for emergency landings and courtesy to people below. Looking up at a hovering helo may seem like you could touch it but unless it's landing or taking off it's probably much higher than 150 feet.

    • report abuse
  2. Bill S. Bill S.

    Bill S

    Sep 23, 2010 - 08:47:22 AM

    I'm convinced that the chopper pilots use the golden dome at M & Wisconsin and then the Q Street Buffalo Bridge as navigational check-offs. This brings them directly over my house all day. I'm OK with this, but what I liked about this article is that some of them don't really need to be flying? I REALLY hate it when the cowboy pilots decide to buzz us just above treetop level and at high speed.

    • report abuse
By posting comments to content found on TBD, you agree to the terms of service.

Post a Comment

You must be signed in to post comments on TBD