On the ground in D.C., Maryland and Virginia

DC9 death: Blood in photo not Mohammed's

November 9, 2010 - 05:59 PM
Text size Decrease Increase
DC9 protest
Protesters angry about a decision to drop all charges in the death outside DC9 carried a poster depicting a bloody crosswalk, but authorities say the blood did not belong to Ali Ahmed Mohammed. (Photo: TBD Staff)

Images published on TBD.com and on the Washington Post's website that purported to show a bloody crosswalk in the vicinity of the DC9 nightclub do not depict the blood of Ali Ahmed Mohammed, according to authorities with knowledge of the case.

The photographs first surfaced on Oct. 15, when reporters descended on the scene near 9th and U streets NW. Mohammed died early that morning following an altercation with five men who worked at the bar. The men were accused of chasing, tackling and beating Mohammed after he allegedly threw one or two bricks through the front window of the bar. Charges of aggravated assault in the case have since been dropped, though the investigation is ongoing, and charges could be re-filed at a later date.

The incident between Mohammed and the five men who were initially arrested, Bill Spieler, Evan Preller, Arthur Zaloga, Reginald Phillips, and Darryl Carter, took place on a sidewalk on 9th Street NW, north of U Street, while the images depict a bloody crosswalk on the south side of U Street, authorities say. In other words, the bloody scene was not the same location where Mohammed was allegedly tackled and restrained by the DC9 employees.

On Monday, more than 100 people gathered to march down Pennsylvania Avenue in protest over U.S. Attorney Ronald C. Machen's decision to drop all charges in the case. At least one protester carried a sign of the bloody crosswalk photograph published by the Post, along with the message, "Whose blood is this?"

In a statement on Friday, Machen explained that prosecutors did not currently have enough evidence to proceed at this time, but that charges could be re-filed once an autopsy report or other evidence becomes available in the case.

Authorities have not said whose blood they think it is — and some law enforcement officials have questioned whether they can be sure the red splotches observed on the crosswalk are blood at all — but one theory goes back to another incident that occurred at DC9 earlier that night. Court records describe 21-year-old Georgio Tuccio of Valhalla, N.Y., who is currently facing a charge of destruction of property for allegedly breaking another window at the bar an hour or so before the incident with Mohammed occurred, as having been "bleeding from the arm" at the time that police and EMTs arrived on the scene.

Tuccio was transported to Howard University Hospital shortly after 1:30 a.m. that morning due to the injury he sustained from allegedly punching out the window, according to a police affidavit. The incident involving Mohammed is reported to have started approximately one hour later, around 2:30 a.m.

Tags:

7 Comments

  • View all

Sort by:

  1. emjsea@yahoo.com emjsea@yahoo.com

    Michael JC

    Nov 10, 2010 - 10:40:17 AM

    GKKA:
    "The fact is Bill Spieler, Evan Preller, Arthur Zaloga, Reginald Phillips, and Darryl Carter have attacked brutally and fatally a man who was under the influence of alchohol. "
    No, this isn't a fact. It hasn't even been established by witnesses let alone in a court of law. In the United States people are presumed innocent until found guilty in a court of law. They aren't guilty because Mohammed's friends claim they are. Since you are such a legal scholar, however, you'll probably want to brush up on the terms "slander" and "libel."

    "they are in the business of getting people drunk"
    Actually, they are not. That's why Mr. Mohammed was turned away. He was drunk and wanted to get more drunk. Being a responsible establishment, DC9 turned him away.

    "Lets give them a lesson kinda. "
    In the United States, we don't use the justice system to teach people a lesson "kind of." Revenge is something for the emotionally retarded and for uncivilized countries.

    "Specially, with the type of connection and money these people got,"
    Clearly you know nothing about the nightclub business. None of the falsely accused have a lot of money or connections of any kind. Owners usually have most or all of there assets in the establishment. Bars, particularly in D.C., are so over regulated and taxed that they barely turn a profit. That's why so many of them don't last through the first year. The reason DC9 has been so successful is because the owners, managers, and employees are stellar examples of professional, law-abiding, and community-minded people.That block and corner of U Street has benefited greatly from the presence of DC9 and its employees.

    "Rest assured that they will face justice appropriately because they did it in the wrong place."
    Are you aware that making threats of violence is illegal?

    • report abuse
  2. diggit diggit

    Brian Gray

    Nov 10, 2010 - 01:47:21 PM

    This article says that "authorities" have made this statement.  Is there anyone saying this on record? Is there any more detail you can offer than just "authorities"?  This is a pretty big deal.  That photo on the front page of the Post was quite inflammatory: that plus Chief Lanier's rash statement were the primary drivers for the widespread assumption of their guilt.  If the Post really made such a grievous error, they need to make a dramatic public apology, but I'm sure they won't. 

    • report abuse
  3. diggit diggit

    Brian Gray

    Nov 11, 2010 - 10:33:04 AM

    Today's Washington Post included a correction about the photo on page A2. Pretty much the same info as in this article. Of course, hardly anyone will see it, and they haven't put the correction on the website, so I can't link to it. And, of course, it certainly is well short of an apology for putting such a misleading image into the public imagination.

    • report abuse
By posting comments to content found on TBD, you agree to the terms of service.

Post a Comment

You must be signed in to post comments on TBD