Donovan McNabb hasn't been what some Skins fans have expected. (Photo: Jay Westcott)

It was assumed Donovan McNabb would be the one deciding whether or not he'd be the Redskins' quarterback for years to come. Now, a lot of fans are debating whether the Skins should even offer him an extension after his contract runs up after this year.

Skins fans knew they'd be getting an upgrade over Jason Campbell, but they thought they'd be getting more than this. We've seen many people saying that they finally understand why the Eagles traded him.

Even with his struggles and his fourth-quarter benching against the Lions, do you still think he gives the Redskins their best chance at winning that they've had in years? Or do we not believe that anymore?

And would you be comfortable seeing him lead the Skins for the next three or four years?