TV Addicts

BTW, was anyone really surprised to find out the judges may have been formulating their opinions based on rehearsals? I thought I recall Simon in an interview talking about how the judges often see the singers on rehearsal/recording day.

hmmm, this lineup is finally looking interesting. but david a.... groan, he is SO boring. what kind of career does he want anyway? he is, in my opinion, the most boring AI singer ever.

Too funny Rush! ROFL!!!! I'm dying!

Thanks for the list too!

Earende

I actually wished that was my problem. Unfortunately I heard them just fine!

It was mediocre at best.

Okay, so Syesha was shierky. David A was boring...nothing new. David C is making bad song choices. And Jason...really, why is he still on AI? He definitely melted down.

Jason was the worst of them last night. forgetting the words, singing off key. Its was terrible. Thank GAWD I taped it. FF'd through most of the torture.

This was one of the first times I watched it live and man I kept hitting my FF button to no avail.

I do have to say, I enjoyed Jason's first song, but the second one just fell apart. I thought he coulda saved it if after the song he said "hey I listened to Dylan sing that song a hundred times and I could never figure out what he was saying". just kidding.

I heard a voice coach review David A this morning he made some sense to me. He said David has a gift, he has a good voice and good looks, but he doesn't have the talent to be a great performer. I think i agree with that, most of the time he sings well but he just doesn't do anything for me, he's just blah or borning as most say. who is voting for this kid. the other thing that bothers me is, do the judges really believe this kid can sell millions of albums. that he has a long career in the music industry. I see him going the way of Taylor Hicks. I can see maybe Broadway in his future. but as a recording artist, nope, no way.

I didn't think Cook was that bad on his first song. It was different than just taking on 2 rocker songs. I think I may download the whole second song from itunes, I kinda liked that one.

Syesha, I'll have to say she's growing on me these last few weeks. I was a firm believer for a long time she was in over her head and should not have even made the top 10, but she's finally finding her zone and I thought she did well last night.

dialidol predictor has Jason at the bottom, it has been right for the last few weeks, even surprised me on the Carly week, it had her last and I didn't think she'd be the one to go.

anyway, hoe all have a wonderful day.

LOL...Rush, as usual, I totally agree with you -- I did tape the show and thanks to FF I think I watched it in 15 minutes. Between David A and Seacrest, oy AI is seriously getting on my nerves this season! Also, like you, I'm liking Syesha... and still hoping for David Cook to win the whole thing.

The one comment I disagree with you: David A on Broadway?! No way. Unless someone writes a show called, "Statues Who Can Sing."

I don't know here.

David does have a good voice, and when he gets older it will get better - and his problem IS his stage presence.

I would not doubt that he could sell records. As long as he doesn't go on the road.

I have to put aside how much I despise him to make that comment!

Max

To this day I never liked Clay Aiken. Ever.

Makes my blood run cold. He reminds me of those Xmas cartoons from Rankin & Bass.

LOL! Della! Right on! As LoraMa said---'statute'.

As for Jason, I saw that snippet on Inside Edition or something. It did look like he mouthed the words 'don't vote'. Didn't have to worry about that from me!!!

Too bad he didn't mouth the words to the song he ripped to shreds night before last.

Got that right!

Now that it's down to three, I would hope everyone is off the David A trip. He is so sickening.

I'm not gonna lie, I was happy for him when he made it to the final twelve, but really didn't think he would get this far!

I could kick my own ass right now!!! ROFL!!

Absolutely Della.

The end is definitely near. As Riggs said, it's like witnessing an implosion.

Hope it goes out while it has some respect left. Whatever rules they changed (and they did) they should have never implemented.

I hope they see what we see. But knowing how greedy people are, they may go on and on and on...

God I hope not.

Used to be a time when you would watch from the auditions and then watch all the way through to see which one made it.

Now it boils down to the auditions.

Most of the exciting things happened on those auditions, like Josiah, the kid who lived in his car, remember him? Or the young lady who's daughter was suffering a debilitating disorder, but she wanted to do this for her. So many of them were better suited then the one's that actually made it. At least we would have had some reason to root for them.

Now it's one long running tired ass joke.

Zen, I ran off on a tangent without really replying to you. Yes, Josiah should have been in the group that made it through auditions. Maybe he'll show up next year. He has had some good things come his way since the show, however. Ellen Degeneres hooked him up with new instruments and lots of top of the line recording equipment. I'm going to go look for him online now.

And the young lady whose daughter had all the problems...I agree, I was quite touched by her, and I really believe she would have worked her tushie off to excel on the show. What a shame.

I can't watch that Della!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Waddareyatryintodotome!

Z.

I read this and almost cried all over again. Those are the memories of AI I want to remember. Not this finale.

Zen, sometimes....you can tug at those heart strings you little devil..didn't realize you could be so....sentimental (did I say that?) LOL!

Max! Leave him alone. He's just having a 'boo-bot' moment.

Oh oh...That's dangerous territory there Smokes!

Boo-bot? LOL!!!

Enjoy it while it lasts peeps!

<hi Smokey>

Kinda nice to have someone stick up for me but....

that Boo-bot remark...I'll give you that one.

ONE!!!!!

And Bot-bot, you cried too...<sniff> u did! U were mad as hell when Josiah didn't make it. You were off-line for a week!

Hey JuneBabaaaaaaaaaaaaay! Like that comment about kicking your own ass! LOL!! Go ahead! Do it! We know u r the real reason David A is still here!

<closet fan> ROFL!!!!