My First Brain Brightening Neurofeedback Sessions
by AnnBanks
Staving off middle-aged decline is nothing if not time-consuming. Neurofeedback usually requires from 20 to 40 sessions to produce lasting results, depending on how quickly your brain responds.
Dr. Merlyn Hurd, my new "brain brightening" therapist, explains this during my first visit to her office. But I put it in perspective by reminding myself that rehabilitating a sports injury also takes time. Dr. Hurd is a friendly woman with red hair and an optimistic manner. I like her immediately. Her office is cheerful and welcoming--the opposite of clinical. First, she goes over with me the principle behind neurofeedback: using nothing more than relaxed focus, you learn to activate a reward. More accurately, your brain learns, with little conscious effort on your part. After a short preamble, she introduces me to her feedback set-up. Its purpose is to encourage my brain's electrical system to perform more efficiently. (Brain scientists define this optimal functioning as having the right ratio of different types of brain waves.) At the beginning of our first outing, Dr. Hurd pastes the electrodes on my scalp using the same hair-gel-type goo. This does not hurt, but afterwards your hair looks as if it had been styled by a three-year-old. My initial feedback consists of a pleasant little chime that sounds when my brain behaves correctly (that is, when I pay attention.) With each ring of the bell, a new nature photograph appears on the computer monitor. The faster the succession of photos, the better I'm doing. I'm a little disappointed because I've read that kids with ADD get to play with video games, in which they do things like use their brain waves to move locomotives along a track. The nature photos, while beautiful, are kind of boring. The pace is slow at first, but by session two I am able to make the pictures move along at a more rapid clip. Not quite at flip-book speed, but faster than before. In session three, the feedback becomes more interesting. I get to propel a roller coaster using my brain. Another reward I especially like is looking at fragmented quotes from Mark Twain, Yogi Berra and Oscar Wilde. In what must be a burst of theta waves, it occurs to me that my favorite quote from Oscar Wilde could serve as a motto for TeeBeeDee's Politics & Commentary section: "In all matters of opinion, our adversaries are insane." After the fourth session, I feel a change. When I leave Dr. Hurd's office, I'm alert and energized. On the way home I polish off a couple of errands that have been languishing on my to-do list. This new zippy me doesn't last for more than an afternoon. But now I have a picture of what "brain brightening" might do if I keep at it. I am beginning to feel optimistic. As the training progresses, I notice my energy level picking up. My to-do list is no longer an exercise in triage, with only emergency items accomplished. Tasks that never seemed to rise high enough on the list miraculously get done. Have I really sorted through my photos and weeded out my office files? I still have "where are my keys?" moments. But fewer than before, as I try to make a point of noticing where I put things. Or even to put them in the same place every time. That is progress. ![]() Have Something to Say? |




Posted: Sep 17, 07 11:47am
Dr. Hurd,
There are certified clinicians in my area who could give me an EEG, and I could get equipment off the Web, as Ann suggests, but what do I tell the clinician to look for, and how do I order equipment or a program that is suited to my needs according to the results of the EEG? I should note that I might be a special challenge because I have ADD as well as middle-aged brain issues. The idea of getting through my entire to-do list is tantalizing, and I would love to try this.
Posted: Sep 17, 07 6:22pm
Dear Nola,
There are many combinations of ADD plus middle-aged brains that are trained successfully with clinicians guiding the process. So, lets look at the issue of equipment first; the neurofeedback equipment is FDA approved medical devices and the manufacturers are required to sell the devices to healthcare physicians. A clinician trained in the analysis of brain function and interpretation of raw EEG activity can design a training program. I do not advocate buying equipment off the Web without guidance or without having received training by a certified /licensed clinician. Although the training looks easy, often the software and ,sometimes, the hardware throws one for a loop. The way I work this is to train the client for several sessions; discuss their comfortability in training themselves or their child ; training them on the use of the software and hardware and then supervising the training via having them e-mail their sessions to my office on a daily basis. They then have office training either every two weeks for one session or once a month. Thus the integrety of the training; supervision; and FDA concerns are met.
Hope this wasn't too long in the explanation.
Merlyn
Posted: Sep 17, 07 2:11pm
You may worry about fading memory and about being too easily distracted, but I'm impressed that someone would have the persistence to report faithfully for all those brain brightening sessions. Showing up is 90 percent of life, and -- this is the part Woody Allen left out -- it's hard work.
Posted: Sep 17, 07 6:24pm
Dr. Hurd,
How can I locate a practitioner in my area? I would love to give this a try. I have had minor some success with meditation, but feel that there is more work than relaxation and breathing techniques can handle. Medication was a bust and only masked the problem.
Posted: Sep 18, 07 2:26pm
Hello EJDA,
Following are some of the websites that have practitioners listed: www.bcia.org(This site lists all practitioners who are certified to practice neurofeedback.) ; www.ISNR.org;www. AAPB.org.
Best and warmest wishes for a good experience in reducing symptoms.
Merlyn
Posted: Sep 23, 07 3:51pm
Question for Dr. Hurd,
I am coming to end of an 18-month certification program (at my local community college) in ultrasound technology. This is not Adult Ed or Continuing Ed or courses for "seniors"- the coursework is for people training for jobs. It has been extremely difficult to retain enough information to pass my courses but I am squeezing by. I just try not to compare myself with the other 12 in my class, all of whom are between the ages of 26 and 45.
I would like to be able to keep learning and retaining information, but I need to do it better than I am now. Things just don't "stick" in my brain as much as I think they should. Especially because I am in a medical field, I want to be getting better all the time. Neurofeedback might help me, but I would like to work with someone who is familiar with middleagers who are re-training for new careers, not people who are taking courses at their leisure and who are not being held responsible for retaining and recalling what is presented in class.
I need to improve not just my recognition abilitiy but more importantly my recall ability. Any suggestions on where to go in Southern California?
Many thanks -
So Cal Gal
Posted: Sep 24, 07 11:30am
Dear Nenuphar ,
Neurofeedback has been found to increase memory functions. The Biofeedback Certification Institute of America has a list of clinicians who have taken an examination plus required courses of study and supervision in order to be certified as clinicians of neurofeedback. The website is www.bcia.org . I had a client very similar to you and she ended up passing all her course work with high colors. Keep it up it is worth it. By the way I know that experience of being older in a class of youngsters. Hey, you bring experience to the issues and that is so valuable for the professor and younger students.
Best
Merlyn Hurd