Posted: May 15, 08
10:33am
(psst, don't let anybody from my Group see this...)
Every once in a while, I allow myself a rant. Yeah, I know, totally non-productive, but...
I am appalled at McCain and Clinton's gas tax holiday idea. This is the most pathetic pandering for votes imaginable.
-- Big disclaimer -- some people are genuinely hurt by high gas taxes and I have sympathy for them, but this ain't the answer. And the only ones that this applies to are those who (1) Absolutely have no choice but to do a lot of driving, for various reasons, AND (2) are of limited financial means and are seriously hurt by this and have no way to cut back elsewhere in their budgets. The number of people who satisfy both of these conditions is fairly small, I am sure, so this amounts to a windfall for most people - including oil companies.
So what happens with gas tax relief? (A) We drive more than we otherwise would!!! Which means oil companies get more money, and our air gets more CO2. (B) We are less sensitive to gas mileage so we keep buying low efficiency vehicles!!! Which means US automakers get more money and keep building those damn things, and in the long run oil companies get more money and our air gets more CO2. (C) Clinton and McCain get more votes -- but wait! A new poll shows that the majority of Americans are opposed to this idea!! Awesome! Maybe pandering for votes won't work this time!
While I am on my high horse, I will say I have very little sympathy for people who spend a lot on big gas-guzzling cars (which are generally more expensive to buy, maintain, and insure than more efficient cars), then whine about gas prices. Hello?!?! Say, here's a crazy thought! Sell that damn thing, buy a cheaper, more efficient car, and with the net profit you can afford not only gas but a lot of other stuff too! Again - exceptions for people who have a genuine need for large, powerful vehicles.
Ok, back to being mr. nice guy...