How to Raise a Perfect Child

AnnBanks

Posted: Oct 31, 07 7:21pm

Helicopter parents? Us? Guilty as charged, I suppose. Or at least half-guilty. Raising our only child, my husband and I traded off the hovering duty, actually. First I would hover over her while he cautioned against it, and then we would swap.

It's annoying when you are following what you believe to be your own unique bent, and some lifestyle journalist comes along and identifies it as a generational trend and gives it a catchy name. I'm sure we baby boomers are more protective than our parents, but that's not necessarily bad. It sometimes seems to me that the post-war approach to parenting was laissez-faire to the point of negligence. I mean it's a miracle we're alive considering some of the things we got up to unsupervised.

What is going on here is a case of generational dialectic. One extreme begets its opposite. I was sure I was doing the right thing when I was being, as my father once cautioned, "too nice" to my daughter. We were visiting the zoo at the time and he got tired of watching me cater to any and all of her whims. I remember feeling indignant over his remark and I failed to consider that there might be a point beneath the provocation.

I still don't want to consider it. Parenting style is made up of hundreds of minute, seemingly insignificant choices every single day. It's hard to imagine that you might have made many of them differently -- might have said no to a second souvenir or soda; might have let your child take the tumble instead of preventing it. You do what you do and things turn out the way they turn out.

Following expert advice does not guarantee that you'll be free of second thoughts. My mother often spoke to me of her regret that she heeded the dictum of a briefly popular childrearing authority who believed that babies should be fed and cuddled on a strict schedule. It didn't matter if they were screaming their heads off and all you wanted to do was pick them up. It was important not to for the sake of their future characters.

Hearing this story, I promised myself to avoid any such regrets. When I became a parent, I would read the current advice books, but I would follow my own heart in child-raising matters. And that is what I did. Until the Zeitgeist shifted, and someone came up with a pejorative term for it.

We boomer parents are now charged with having been narcissistically over-involved with our kids, and having coddled them to the point of undermining their independence. On one level I understand that this is just another swing of the pendulum. On another, I worry that the description fits. In any case, by the time a child leaves for college, the job is done. The choices are adding up as they will. You do what you do, things turn out the way they turn out. You might just as well regret that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west.

23 Comments // 15 Members

Posted: Oct 31, 07 7:57pm

Helicopter parents? Us? Guilty as charged, I suppose. Or at least half-guilty. Raising our only child, my husban...

Are you saying that you have become your mother?

Thats not so bad, you turned out okay.....didn't you?

Posted: Oct 31, 07 8:57pm

Are you saying that you have become your mother?

Thats not so bad, you turned out okay.....didn't you?...

My husband used to say to me when my son was a baby/toddler that I needed to let go [meaning i was being too protective.] Now that my son has left for college, mu husband is having a difficult time letting go. If my son doesnt call him every evening usually by 9:30 pm, my husband calls him.

When i was growing up i raised myself and my younger siblings..... all 5 of them. Boy, did that teach me something i.e., prolong becoming a parent as long as possible.

I remember>>>>>>>

broken bones, broken down refrigerator and rotting food, dirty dishes and laundry piling up, teenage pregnancy, you name it.....this was just life and my parents were not accused of being negligent, abusive or insane. Oh, bring back the good ole' days!

Posted: Oct 31, 07 11:04pm

Helicopter parents? Us? Guilty as charged, I suppose. Or at least half-guilty. Raising our only child, my husban...

If you really thing your job as a parent is done when the child leaves for college you are in for a rude awakening! Once a parent, always a parent.

All we can do is our best as we try to improve from one generation to the next and we will make an entirely new set of "mistakes" than our own parents made as we raise our children.

My own five children are now adults, some with children of their own.

Kids are awesome and grandchildren are such a sweet reward. My mother was right about one thing--you can spoil the grandchildren then send them home!

Posted: Nov 1, 07 7:50am

If you really thing your job as a parent is done when the child leaves for college you are in for a rude awakening! Onc...

People do speak highly of grandchildren so I am eager to experience this delight. But I tell myself that I shouldn't be too eager. Like a lot of my peers, I was an "older mother," but I'm hoping that the pendulum will have swung once again and that my daughter's generation will start their families earlier.

Posted: Nov 1, 07 8:46am

Helicopter parents? Us? Guilty as charged, I suppose. Or at least half-guilty. Raising our only child, my husban...

There is no such thing as the perfect child, nor do perfect parents exist either. Raising kids to turn out right is a gamble and, as parents, we hope that we are doing the right things, calling the right shots.

Beyond the basics of being firm and fair and showing love, each set of parents applies their own judgements to what else is needed to raise a child. There is no one set of rules that works for everybody.

My Grandfather used to say that he had to be mad at his kids half of his life to raise them decent. That seems a bit harsh but they all turned out right. So, who knows? Hopefully, we'll do the best that we can to mold honest living citizens.

Posted: Nov 1, 07 5:43pm

There is no such thing as the perfect child, nor do perfect parents exist either. Raising kids to turn out right is a ga...

I hope that our children's generation has babies not only sooner, but also more often. We've cheated ourselves by having too few children too late -- and if you ask the kids, many of them regret not having siblings. Am I wrong to envy cultures that promote large families, like the Mormons and the Hasidim?

Posted: Nov 1, 07 7:57pm

There is no such thing as the perfect child, nor do perfect parents exist either. Raising kids to turn out right is a ga...

Enjoy the journey--whether it be as an older mother with young children, as a parent of teenagers or as a grandparent. It is all a part of life's process and we tend to wish our lives away, ya know what I mean? When the baby learns to walk, when the kids go to school, when the kids leave home, etc. Every stage has its good and bad points and we can learn so much along the way!