It's Confidential...?

TheInquiringEye

Posted: Aug 5, 08 1:22pm

What does the word 'confidential' mean to you?

When someone says, 'I need to talk with you. Please keep it confidential..' to what extent are you willing to comply with their request? I'm not so much talking about a juicy rumor, (although I could be), rather I am referring to moral, ethical, even legal issues.

If they told you that they knew of a violent crime, or a crime against a child, would you tell? Is there any extreme which would lead you to break your oath?

Personally, when someone confides in TheIquiringEye, they may as well be talking to a priest. I will not, under any circumstances, break that oath. I certainly might try to convince them to channel their energies toward a positive outcome, but I'd go to hell before what they told me left my lips. That may very well not be the best answer; I'm wrong alot. But unless I'm convinced differently, it's how I choose to live my life. (And ofcourse, if convinced differently, I would not agree to hear the secret in the first place...)

Things can go from noble to dicey pretty fast in these situations, and I wonder, just who else shares my sentiments and what limitations to you place on your silence.

JackieRodzinski

TheInquiringEye

27 Comments // 22 Members

Posted: Aug 5, 08 1:23pm

It depends on the situation. When I managed a big company, if an employee approached me and wanted to tell me something confidential, I would explain that if it involved wrongdoing within the company, I could not be bound as my first duty to was to address the wrongdoing. As memory serves (and it's not such a reliable servant these days) no employee ever demurred after being told that.

When one of my kids has told me something in confidence, I sometimes feel that I must tell the parent of the child involved in the story, and I have been able to convince my kids that they must let me do that.

When a friend confides, however, I can promise to keep it secret to my death.

Posted: Aug 5, 08 1:40pm

When a friend confides, however, I can promise to keep it secret to my death.

Even if that friend confides the deatails of a crime? What about if the secret involves the betrayal of a loved one?

TIE

Posted: Aug 5, 08 1:50pm

On a few occasions I have been asked to be someone's repeated alibi. They were both involved in affairs. Interesting thing happens when you are put in that situation, you begin to accept that behavior as ok and it's not. What I learned in both instances, when I person is lying to everyone around them, including themselves, it will back fire, blow up and take you down with them. Can I keep a secret? Yes. Will I ever put myself in that situation? Absolutely not. A true friend would not put you in a compromising situation.

PS...as much fun as my friends and I are, the only laws we break are driving a bit too fast and jaywalking. I was witness to a heap of crap when I was hanging out with cops. Those days are over.

Posted: Aug 5, 08 1:58pm

there was a point in my life many years ago when i would go to jail for people.

these days, if the stakes are that high, its best that i not know about.

knowingly exposing oneself to that kind of vulnerability isn't worth the brain damage.

Posted: Aug 15, 08 7:59am

Depends on the person. If I tell my wife something in trust and she passed it on I would be really hurt. Others not so much

Posted: Aug 15, 08 8:11am

when i tell someone information in confidence, it is information that i don't mind if it gets out.

actual confidential info is in the lock box. so my point is, if i tell someone something, my assumption is that it is 'out there.'

TexasGma
TexasGma
Founding Member

Posted: Aug 15, 08 8:23am

I am a good confidant w/ easy stuff. But I make it clear I do not want to know any heavy stuff. However I don''t know anyone who would be involved in any heavy stuff so I don't have to worry. If a friend ever confided in me about an extra marital affair I would have to tell them straight up to get help & stop it immediately. I just don't believe in that kind of stuff & someone will get hurt & I so not want to be a part of it.

Cami