So Am I Wrong to Pass On the Family Holidays This Year?

Laura27

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:16pm

My husband and I will be adopting a little one this Spring from China. She will be our first child and we are thrilled and excited beyond words.

The problem? My mother-in-law has not been the least bit supportive of this whole adoption thing. From the first time we mentioned the word "adoption", she'd shush us and say, "Uh, uh, uh! I don't want to hear about adoption... You two just have to keep trying." Naturally, she, like any other grandmother, would have liked a biological, "blood" grandchild... but it's just not happening and we can't do anything about it. (trust me, we've tried) Though she hasn't quite said so, she's shown us that she can't come to terms with, let alone "love", a baby from a different culture. It's been three years now that my husband and I have been tolerating ignorant comments from her (and her twin daughters from another marriage) like: "But why didn't you adopt from Russia so you could get a blonde, blue-eyed baby?"... "China? Why China???"... "Why not Korea... those babies are so much cuter!"... "Are you sure you don't want to try in-vitro?"... "Have you considered getting a surrogate-mother?"... "Did you check out Dave Thomas' adoption website?? You can request the type of baby you want... like blonde and blue-eyed!".

The "TYPE" of baby??? There is no "type" of baby that we want. All we want is "a" baby... and hopefully, we pray, a healthy one. Our daughter will be Chinese... we're Italian... so she won't look like us... so what?? Doesn't mean she won't love pasta and soccer like every good Italian! She'll be just like us every other way. But Grandma doesn't get this... she's still hoping for a blonde-blue eyed grandchild... one that looks like her (never mind us -- neither my husband nor I are blonde and blue eyed!).

We went to my MIL's this Saturday for a birthday celebration. Nice meal, great cake, blow out the candles, and what's the next thing that comes out of MIL's mouth? "So WHY is it you aren't adopting from Russia???". Still? Must we STILL put up with questions like this after three years in the China adoption program? And as if that weren't enough, she followed this brilliant remark with "Oh, I just saw my friend and her adopted baby the other day... Oh, that baby is SO cute!! She doesn't even look Chinese!"

It's been three years of this and I've finally taken a stance. (I've been polite and have held back from lashing back at her ever since.) I will not be celebrating Christmas, New Year's or any other holiday/occassion at my MIL's anymore. Grandma is embarrassed to have a Chinese granddaughter, so our little one will simply not be a part of her life. I feel awful because this is my husband's family, but I just can't stand these cutting, hurtful, ignorant, discriminatory remarks anymore. My husband can go see his family if he chooses, but I will no longer be a part of those visits. Am I wrong???

34 Comments // 29 Members

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:27pm

Congratulations on your prospective baby! Will she be called Spring? Don't let the MIL get you down. Hope to see a picture sometime.

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:37pm

I have two Chinese nieces and they are the cutest most loving girls. Good luck

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:39pm

Don't let your MiL get to you. It's in their job description to do that.

As far as adopting goes, for whatever it is worth (probably damned little), you move right to the top of the Nick Danger Admiration Society. When I was married, my then-wife and I looked into adopting and we met some unbelievable people along the way (we split up before we had a chance to adopt).

One might suspect that your in-laws might change their minds when they actually get to see your daughter but if they don't, it's their loss.

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:39pm

Am I wrong???

You are right. Stick to your guns until they make amends.

And congratulations!

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:42pm

Laura, you are doing the right thing, you do not need to justify your choice to anyone. Besides why would you want your new baby to be around such ignorant and racist people as that. They will be the ones who will be losing out. Hang in there.

MarkTrost
MarkTrost

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:49pm

No. You’re not wrong.

Your husband is.

He is silently siding with his mother and allowing you to assume full responsibility for the emotional and physical separation from his family.

“My husband can go visit if he choose..” I don’t understand that. Why would he choose to associate with them? What does he intend to do once his daughter arrives? If he can’t take a moral stand against his family now - how much of a stand will he take for his daughter when she requires it? If he isn’t raising a voice against his mother’s racist rants - and he isn’t raising a voice in your defense - and he isn’t raising a voice for a child who hasn’t yet found her voice - what is he doing while his mother razes a family? He’d better decide what he intends to stand for and stand against before he assumes the role of raising a child.

You’re not wrong. But your husband sounds like an ass.

Posted: Dec 1, 08 12:49pm

Congratulations on becoming a mother. Back in the 90s, a dear friend adopted a mixed-race American baby and the prospect left her mother undone -- calling her local nuns and priests in desperation to see if anything could avoid the disaster of her having a black grandchild. Guess what -- as soon as the baby arrived, she loved her granddaughter and the awful things she said/did were forgotten in the joy of a new family. She now has three black grandchildren and the last I heard was a great grandmother. I hope your MIL follows this pattern and you will be able to forgive her.